Commission for Prevention and Protection against Discrimination should protect the rights of marginalized citizens, not the profits of private companies

ANNOUNCEMENT
Commission for Prevention and Protection against Discrimination should protect the rights of marginalized citizens, not the profits of private companies
The Association HOPS Options for Healthy Life Skopje and the Network for Protection against Discrimination addressed the Commission for Prevention and Protection against Discrimination with a complaint about a case of indirect discrimination based on health status. A woman who has been treated for hepatitis C in the past has not been provided with private health insurance. The private insurance company does not provide this right to other people who in the past or now are being treated for various diseases. In this way, insurance companies discriminate on the basis of health status and belonging to a marginalized group of people who use drugs and other groups of patients treated for various chronic diseases.
The Commission for Prevention and Protection against Discrimination, acting upon the complaint, adopted an opinion which did not establish indirect discrimination on the basis of health status towards the persons who use drugs, but also towards other persons with chronic diseases.
According to the Commission, avoiding the risk of financial loss is a legitimate aim to discriminate against different groups of patients whether they are currently being treated or cured of an illness. In this way, the Commission incorrectly applies the Law on Prevention and Protection against Discrimination, which defines what can be a legitimate goal, such as: to achieve that goal, as well as to be proportionate to the effects to be achieved. ” According to the Commission, is the profit of the insurance company a real need and is the discrimination of the patients a necessary way to achieve that goal ?!
This practice is contrary to international standards in the field. According to the European Convention on Human Rights, legitimate goals for restricting rights can be state security, protection of health and morals, protection from crime and protection of the rights of others. The profit of private companies can not be considered more important than the equality of citizens as their constitutional and internationally recognized right.
The Commission refers to the provisions in the field of private health insurance without taking into account that discrimination sometimes originates from the laws themselves. If something is regulated in law does not mean that it can not be discrimination. It should be borne in mind that these persons are completely excluded from the right to private health insurance. For people with chronic illnesses that affect the amount of health care they receive, companies can provide a way to pay and calculate the actual cost of treatment, but not a complete waiver.
Considering that this Commission according to the Law should be an expert and independent body for prevention and protection against discrimination, the fact that this body is not sensitive enough in terms of violation of the rights of marginalized communities, which includes different groups of chronically ill patients, is particularly worrying. and people who use or have used drugs.
Skopje, 10.11.21
Contact person:
Margarita Gligurovska
077953787