NPAD Opinion: Compulsory vaccination is not an illegal restriction of rights or discrimination

NPAD Opinion: Compulsory vaccination is not an illegal restriction of rights or discrimination

The Network for Protection against Discrimination[1] fully supports the measures proposed by the Commission for Infectious Diseases in the area of ​​prevention of the spread of COVID-19 virus.

As organizations committed to the protection of human rights, we believe that stricter measures to ensure greater coverage of immunization are inevitable if we aim to protect the life and health of people. We remind you that individual rights can and should be subject to restriction when there is a higher value behind the purpose of the restriction, as in the case of protection of the health and life of all. On the contrary, the failure of the authorities to take measures to protect the population of Covid-19 may, in certain circumstances, be considered a violation of human rights. Mandatory vaccination is a necessary measure given the serious effect of global disinformation campaigns that produce distrust of science and medical authorities and directly affect the small number of vaccinated. The duty to protect and promote our own health and the health of others is the highest civic obligation. According to Article 39 of the Constitution of the Republic of North Macedonia, every citizen is guaranteed the right to health care, and the citizen has the right and duty to protect and promote his own health and the health of others. Compulsory vaccination, which is provided by the Law on Protection of the Population from Infectious Diseases, can at no time be suspected of being contrary to the Constitution and fundamental human rights and freedoms. Pursuant to Article 33 paragraph 7 of this Law, the Minister, upon the proposal of the Commission for Infectious Diseases, may prescribe vaccination for other infectious diseases. Hence, the Network for Protection against Discrimination considers that it is justified by law to oblige the citizens to vaccination against diseases whose prevention is in the interest of the society. We live in a pandemic, where all relevant available and scientifically based data suggest that vaccination against Covid-19 is in the interest of preserving public health and is a legitimate goal of restricting human rights.

Everyone has the right to protection and health in the workplace. That is why we believe that the Commission should not differentiate between public and private sector workers when creating measures. Second, the resistance expressed by workers ‘representatives indicates the need for a broad social and professional discussion that will include all relevant factors (trade unions and citizens’ associations) and competent institutions (Commission for Infectious Diseases, Ministry of Health, State Labor Inspectorate, MLSP, Commission for Prevention and Protection against Discrimination). The absence of such dialogue can have the greatest impact on workers, who will suffer the most from the harmful consequences of disagreements with social actors, in a way that will discourage them from being vaccinated and thus protecting themselves from Covid-19 and its consequences.

These measures are also within the framework of international law and practice of protection of human rights. According to the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in the case of Vavřička and Others v. the Czech Republic Compulsory vaccination of children is not a violation of the European Convention on Human Rights and Freedoms but is necessary in a democratic society. Mandatory vaccination restricts the right to privacy (Article 8 of the ECHR) which may be restricted for the protection of public health. The court in its judgment addresses the proportionality of the measure and sets a wide margin of discretion for states to decide best positioned to adopt appropriate measures to protect public health. The measure is considered proportionate, with a legitimate aim, protection of the population from diseases. In judging, it is important to consider the question of whether there is an urgent social need, and given the fact that KOVID-19 still poses a serious threat to public health despite the low percentage of vaccinated, it can easily be concluded that such a need exists. The verdict emphasizes that vaccination is a widely accepted, effective and efficient way of protecting health and that due to the reduction in the number of voluntarily vaccinated countries take more restrictive measures to provide vaccination as mandatory vaccination followed by penalties or conditional enjoyment of other vaccination rights.

In the case of the French firefighters against France (Abgrall and 671 Others v. France 41950/21), in which they asked the ECtHR to suspend the obligation to vaccinate, as well as any related measures that could be taken and which could be prohibited The ECtHR rejected the request because it considered it to be outside the scope of Rule 39, according to which the court may adopt interim measures, such as urgent measures in order to The Court emphasized that Rule 39 applies only in cases where one faces a real risk of irreversible damage.

At the national level, the Commission for Prevention and Protection against Discrimination in July this year adopted an opinion according to which the mandatory vaccination of children as a condition for enrolling in primary education does not constitute discrimination on any grounds. The Commission adopted a general recommendation stating that laws, measures, recommendations and other relevant acts aimed at preventing, treating and controlling the situation of epidemic, endemic and other diseases do not constitute a violation of the right to privacy of the individual, his personal and family life and of dignity and reputation.

For all the above reasons, the Network for Protection against Discrimination considers that such measures are necessary, they do not constitute discrimination because the protection of public health is a legitimate goal.

…

[1] Open Society Foundation – Macedonia, HERA – Association for Health Education and Research, HOPS – Options for Healthy Life – Skopje, Helsinki Committee for Human Rights, LGBTI Support Center, LET Station – Prilep, Coalition MARGINI, Stronger Together, NATIONAL NETWORK to End Violence Against Women and Domestic Violence.

Similar Posts

  • Handbook on Legal Empowerment and Inclusive Innovation: How it developed the idea for LET Club?

    “… LET Station points out the importance of how crucial it is to involve all potential stakeholders in the last period of the whole process of developing the idea of ​​a social enterprise, a real community with which the organization works. Co-developing, testing, and iterating upon many different concepts has been a long journey, but they are excited by the possibilities…

  • Internal training for creating a Communication Strategy

    “Communication and public representation are key to the organization’s transparency and visibility.” Within the project: “Transparent action for accountable conducting”, implemented by the Association for Legal Education and Transparency LET STATION, on 18.09.2020, in the premises of the association was held Internal training for creating a Communication Strategy. The project is implemented in the period June-November…

  • A Stronger System for Fairer Protection – A New Project to Combat Corruption in Healthcare

    The implementation of the project “A Stronger System for Fairer Protection: Reducing Corruption in Healthcare” has officially begun. The project’s main goal is to help build a transparent and accountable healthcare system that responds to the needs of all citizens—especially women and marginalized groups. This national initiative is structured around three key components: training healthcare…

  • Vesna Sapkoski from L.E.T. Station is one of the winners of the 2019 Legal Empowerment Leadership Course Award

    Each year, for the past 5 years, Namati and the Legal Empowerment Network have collaborated with partners to run the Legal Empowerment Leadership Course at the Central European University in Budapest. The aim of the one-week course is to cultivate a global cadre of leaders who are committed to legal empowerment, and who share a common understanding…

  • STOP the poisoning! – environmental justice for the citizens of Prilep

    The right to safety and a safe environment is inviolable and no one must compromise it for any interest, bigger business or political! Како здружение кое работи на заштита и унапредување на правата на граѓаните за безбедна и здрава животна средина, Станица ПЕТ на 12.09.2023 година поднесе пријава до повеќе институции за досегашното непостапување на…

  • The great victories of the common people – success stories from our work

    As part of our daily legal and paralegal assistance, apart from solving regular legal and administrative problems that citizens face, we also come across extremely complex cases, where citizens have been stuck in institutional labyrinths for years, without the opportunity to exercise their rights. Although justice can sometimes be slow, it is not unattainable. The…